How to Hire Customer Services Staff

Posted on Tuesday, November 17, 2026 by Lizzie Jolly, Associate Director, Love Success

If you need to hire customer service staff, the best approach is to start with the customer experience you want to deliver, then work backwards to define the skills, experience and personality your new hire needs. A good customer services recruitment agency can help you do this, giving you access to suitable, pre-screened candidates while saving you time during the hiring process.

Customer service is one of those functions where the wrong hire can have a surprisingly wide impact. Your customer service team is often the first human interaction someone has with your business, so how they communicate, solve problems and handle pressure matters.

What should you look for when hiring customer service staff?

It is tempting to focus heavily on previous customer service experience. While this can be important, it shouldn't be the only thing you look for.

A candidate who has spent five years answering customer queries isn't automatically a better hire than someone with a small amount of experience who is an excellent communicator, highly organised and naturally good at resolving problems.

For most customer service roles, you should look for a combination of:

  • Clear and confident communication
  • Empathy and emotional intelligence
  • Patience and resilience
  • Problem-solving ability
  • Good attention to detail
  • Organisation and time management
  • Confidence using technology and CRM systems (or ability to learn them)
  • The ability to stay calm under pressure
  • A genuine interest in helping people
  • Reliability and professionalism

You should also think about the particular environment the person will be working in.

A customer service adviser dealing with hundreds of straightforward enquiries a day needs a different skill set from a client services executive managing long-term relationships with high-value customers.

What should you include in a customer service job description?

A vague job description can make recruitment considerably harder and less successful.

If your advert simply says you're looking for someone with "excellent communication skills and a customer-focused attitude", you'll probably receive applications from a very broad range of candidates.

Instead, be specific about what the person will actually do.

Your job description should cover:

Area

What to explain

Responsibilities

What will the person handle day to day?

Customers

Who will they communicate with?

Communication

Phone, email, live chat, face-to-face or a mixture?

Systems

Which CRM, ticketing or database systems will they use?

Targets

Are there response times, sales targets or service-level agreements?

Working environment

Office-based, hybrid or remote?

Hours

Standard hours, shifts, evenings or weekends?

Experience

What experience is genuinely essential?

Personality

What type of person will work well in your team?

Progression

Is there scope to develop into a senior or specialist role?

 

Be particularly careful about separating essential requirements from things that would simply be useful and can be learned.

What customer service skills should you assess during interviews?

Try not to ask interview questions such as "Are you good with difficult customers?" Everyone knows to say yes! Instead, ask candidates to describe situations where they've demonstrated the skill you're interested in. Even better, ask them for an example and then also give them a realistic scenario and ask how they would handle it.

You're looking at how the candidate thinks.

Do they listen first? Do they acknowledge the customer's frustration? Do they take ownership? Do they know when to escalate? Can they remain calm?

You can assess candidates against a simple checklist:

Customer service interview checklist

  • Communication is clear and professional
  • Listens rather than simply waiting to respond
  • Demonstrates empathy
  • Takes responsibility for resolving problems
  • Can explain decisions clearly
  • Remains calm when discussing difficult situations
  • Understands when to escalate an issue
  • Shows good judgement
  • Can prioritise competing requests
  • Gives examples rather than relying on generic answers

For more technical customer service roles, you may also want to test CRM knowledge, written communication, data accuracy or the ability to learn new systems.

Should you hire for experience or attitude?

Ideally, you want both. But if you have to choose, consider which skills are genuinely difficult to teach.

You can train someone to use your CRM. You can teach them your products, processes and internal systems. It is much harder to teach someone to genuinely care about customers, listen properly, communicate with empathy and remain composed when somebody is frustrated.

This is why a good customer services recruitment agency will look beyond a CV.

We focus on matching capability with character. Candidates are assessed not just for their experience but for whether they are proactive, dependable and comfortable working in the type of environment you're hiring for.

That distinction can be particularly important when you're hiring for a customer-facing position where personality and behaviour directly affect the customer experience.

What types of customer service staff can you hire?

"Customer service" covers a huge range of roles. Depending on your organisation, you might need:

  • Customer Service Advisors
  • Customer Service Representatives
  • Customer Support Executives
  • Customer Support Specialists
  • Customer Experience Agents
  • Client Services Coordinators
  • Client Support Executives
  • Customer Care Advisors
  • Contact Centre Advisors
  • Call Centre Advisors
  • Helpdesk and Service Desk Analysts
  • Chat Support Agents
  • Customer Success Executives
  • Customer Success Managers
  • Member Services Advisors
  • Complaints and Resolution Specialists

The terminology can also vary between sectors. A professional services firm might call someone a Client Services Executive, while a technology company may use Customer Success Executive or Customer Support Specialist.

So, when you're recruiting, concentrate on the responsibilities rather than getting too hung up on the job title.

How quickly can you hire customer service staff?

This depends on the role, location, availability of suitable candidates and how specific your requirements are. It also depends on whether you want temps (quick to hire) or permanent staff (usually slightly longer).

If you're hiring for a straightforward customer service position and are open to immediately available candidates, you may be able to move relatively quickly.

Specialist roles can take longer, particularly if you need specific industry experience, technical knowledge or unusual working hours.

Importantly, communicate with your recruiter about expectations. If the best candidates are likely on long notice periods, it should be possible to use temporary customer service workers in the meantime.

How can you attract better customer service candidates?

Salary is obviously important, but it isn't the only factor candidates consider.

If you want strong applicants, make sure your vacancy explains what they will get from the role, not just what you expect to get from them.

Consider highlighting:

  • Working arrangements and flexibility
  • Location and commuting expectations
  • Salary range
  • Benefits
  • Training
  • Career progression
  • Team culture
  • The type of customers they will work with
  • The level of responsibility they'll have
  • Any specialist knowledge they'll gain

What are the biggest mistakes employers make when hiring customer service staff?

There are a few common ones.

1.         Hiring from the CV alone

A CV can tell you where someone has worked. It doesn't necessarily tell you how they behave when a customer is upset.

2.         Overlooking transferable skills

Retail, hospitality, reception, administration and other people-facing roles can provide excellent customer service experience.

3.         Making the job sound generic

If you don't explain what makes your customer service environment different, you may struggle to attract people who are genuinely interested in it.

4.         Making the recruitment process too long

Strong customer service candidates are often comfortable communicating and may be attractive to several employers. If your process takes weeks, you risk losing them.

5.         Ignoring cultural fit

Someone can have an impressive customer service CV but still be completely wrong for your team.

6.         Failing to plan for peak periods

If you know your busiest periods are coming, don't wait until you're already overwhelmed before looking for temporary support.

How can a customer services recruitment agency help?

A specialist customer services recruitment agency can take much of the workload away from your internal team.

Instead of advertising a role, waiting for applications, screening CVs, arranging initial interviews and discovering that many applicants aren't suitable, you can chat with a recruiter who knows the right questions to ask to really uncover what you need. They then use their skills and network to bring you a very focused shortlist. They can assess skills and support your entire process.

We are consultative: understanding the team, culture and priorities before sourcing and assessing candidates.

What can you learn from a real customer service recruitment project?

We’ve worked with a large national visa processing organisation where customer service recruitment involved more than simply finding people with good communication skills.

The client needed multiple locations covered, alongside complex vetting and compliance requirements. We achieved a 100% fill rate across all locations, with many temporary workers completing year-long assignments and consistent quality across a geographically dispersed workforce.

When you're recruiting at volume, you need to consider consistency, onboarding, compliance, retention and whether people can operate effectively within your processes.

How do you choose between customer service recruitment agencies in London?

If you're comparing customer service recruitment agencies London businesses use, don't simply ask how many CVs an agency can send you.

Ask questions such as:

  • Do you recruit specifically for customer service roles?
  • Do you understand our sector?
  • Can you provide temporary as well as permanent staff?
  • How do you assess candidates?
  • Do you reference temporary workers?
  • How quickly can you provide a shortlist?
  • Can you recruit at volume if we need several people?
  • Can you support complex vetting requirements?
  • What happens if the candidate isn't the right fit?
  • Will we have one point of contact throughout the process?

The answers should give you a much clearer idea of whether the agency will genuinely reduce your workload or simply add another layer to it.

What should you do before you brief a recruitment agency?

You don't need everything worked out perfectly before speaking to a recruiter. In fact, a good recruiter should help you make the brief.

But it helps to have answers to these questions:

Role: What will the person actually be doing?

Customers: Who will they deal with?

Channels: Phone, email, chat, face-to-face or all four?

Systems: What software will they use?

Hours: What are the working hours and flexibility requirements?

Location: Where will they work and how often must they be in the office?

Experience: What is genuinely essential?

Salary: What is your realistic budget?

Start date: When do you need them?

Contract: Permanent, temporary, fixed-term or temp-to-perm?

Personality: What type of person succeeds in your existing team?

The clearer you are about these points, the easier it is for a recruiter to find the right person.

Frequently asked questions about hiring customer service staff

What qualifications do customer service staff need?

There is no universal qualification required for most customer service roles. Communication, problem-solving, organisation and interpersonal skills are often more important than formal qualifications, although specialist sectors may have their own requirements.

Is previous customer service experience essential?

Not always. Candidates from retail, hospitality, reception, administration and other customer-facing environments can have highly transferable skills.

Should customer service staff be office-based?

Not necessarily. The right arrangement depends on your business, customers, systems and team. Customer service recruitment can cover office-based, hybrid and, where appropriate, remote positions.

Can I hire temporary customer service staff?

Temporary staff can be useful for seasonal demand, urgent cover, long-term absence, projects or periods of business growth. Temp-to-perm recruitment can also give both sides an opportunity to establish whether the arrangement works before making a permanent commitment.

How do recruitment agencies vet customer service candidates?

This varies between agencies. At Love Success, candidates are interviewed and assessed for experience and suitability (often in advance of a new vacancy so we can move fast).

How much does it cost to use a customer service recruitment agency?

Fees vary depending on the type of recruitment, role, salary, volume and whether you need temporary or permanent staff. It is worth looking at the overall cost rather than simply comparing headline fees, including the time your internal team would otherwise spend sourcing, screening and interviewing candidates. 60% of our clients have worked with us over a decade – that speaks volumes about our value added.

Ready to hire customer service staff?

If you need to hire customer service staff in London or elsewhere in the UK, we can help you recruit for temporary, contract and permanent customer service positions across a wide range of sectors.

Find out more about hiring customer service staff with Love Success and speak to the team about what you need on 020 7870 7177.

 

Previous PostNext Post