If you’re an HR professional dealing with increasingly lengthy workplace complaints, AI-generated grievances may be part of the reason. Employees can now use tools such as ChatGPT to organise their thoughts, draft formal complaints and produce detailed grievances in minutes. This can help employees articulate genuine concerns, but it can also create additional work for HR teams who need to establish the facts, check accuracy and respond fairly.
So, how should you approach AI-written grievances without making the process unnecessarily difficult for either side?
Why are employees using AI to write workplace grievances?
Writing a formal grievance can be daunting, particularly when an employee is upset, worried about their job or unsure how to explain what has happened. Aggrieved employees can also use AI as a form of search engine to identify whether there is a legal basis and how to apply it in their case.
AI can make the process feel much easier. An employee might type a few notes into a chatbot and ask it to turn them into a formal workplace grievance. The result may be considerably longer and more structured than the employee would have written themselves. Many people do not then go through what the AI tool produces and reduce it down, or even fact-check what the AI tool has produced.
But for employees, there are some genuine benefits.
AI can help an employee:
- organise a series of events chronologically
- identify the key points they want to raise
- improve spelling and grammar
- explain their concerns more clearly
- structure supporting evidence
- feel more confident about raising a difficult issue.
For employees who struggle with written communication, this can be particularly useful. It is important that employers do not assume that an AI-assisted grievance is less genuine simply because the wording sounds unusually polished.
The employee's underlying concerns still need to be considered.
Can AI-generated grievances create more work for HR?
Yes. The difficulty is not necessarily the use of AI itself. It is the potential gaps between the length of the document and the information HR needs to investigate the complaint and the facts (both the grievance and the wider legal framework) of what’s produced by the AI tool.
An employee may provide a grievance running to several thousand words when the underlying issue could be explained in a few paragraphs.
AI can also produce confident-sounding statements that are inaccurate, exaggerated or based on assumptions. It may introduce language such as "breach", "discrimination", "harassment" or "constructive dismissal" without the employee fully understanding the legal significance of those terms.
That means HR needs to separate what the employee is saying happened from how an AI tool has described it.
The important questions remain:
- What actually happened?
- When did it happen?
- Who was involved?
- What evidence exists?
- What does the employee believe should happen now?
- Does anything require further investigation?
The technology may have changed how a grievance arrives on your desk, but it has not changed the fundamentals of handling one fairly.
How should you assess an AI-written grievance?
Don't be distracted by the writing style.
A beautifully structured grievance needs the same scrutiny as a few lines accompanying an email trail, while a poorly written complaint may contain an entirely legitimate and serious concern.
A useful approach is to break the grievance down into three categories:
|
Look at
|
What you need to establish
|
|
Facts
|
What happened, and when?
|
|
Evidence
|
What documents, messages or witnesses support the account?
|
|
Interpretation
|
What does the employee believe the events mean or amount to?
|
This can make an extremely long grievance much more manageable. If you have strong tech safeguards in place for protecting data, you could even use AI tools yourself to help draw out these points from the grievance!
Importantly, avoid assuming that every statement generated by AI is factually correct. If an employee has included employment-law terminology or references to policies, legislation or previous cases, check the underlying facts rather than simply accepting the wording.
The same principle applies when an employee makes allegations about another member of staff. The grievance should be investigated on its merits, not judged by how persuasive or professionally written it sounds.
Should you have a policy on ChatGPT and workplace grievances?
It is sensible to give employees clear guidance on the use of AI at work, but you should be careful about creating a rule that effectively discourages employees from using AI to help them communicate.
Instead, your guidance could explain what is and isn't appropriate.
For example, employees could be reminded:
- not to include confidential company information in public AI tools
- not to share another employee's personal information
- to check AI-generated information for accuracy
- that they remain responsible for the content they submit (both to AI tools and to others, e.g. HR)
- that AI can help with structure and wording but should not invent facts or evidence
- that a grievance should reflect their own experience and concerns.
This is particularly important as AI in HR becomes more widespread. Your policy should cover more than grievances if employees are using generative AI for recruitment, performance reviews, correspondence, research or other workplace tasks.
Should you encourage employees to raise concerns informally first?
Where appropriate, our answer to this is always yes.
An early conversation frequently prevents a relatively straightforward workplace issue becoming a lengthy formal grievance.
If an employee is unhappy about workload, communication, a colleague's behaviour or a management decision, giving them an accessible route to raise the issue early and informally can make a significant difference.
That doesn’t mean making employees jump through informal hoops before they are allowed to raise a formal grievance – it’s about heading issues off at the pass.
Some matters are too serious for an informal conversation, and an employee may have good reason to want a formal process immediately.
The aim is simply to make the informal route easy and approachable where it is appropriate.
Your grievance policy should start with the basic tenets of:
· Here’s who you can speak to
· Here’s what happens next
How can HR handle a very long AI-generated grievance?
Don't feel that you need to respond to every paragraph individually.
Instead, acknowledge the grievance and identify the key issues that need investigation.
You might then use the grievance meeting to clarify points, ask questions and establish which allegations are supported by evidence.
This is where the human element remains particularly important. At the end of the day, the written grievance is only ever the starting point – it’s not the entire grievance process.
A conversation can reveal that a seemingly serious allegation is actually a misunderstanding. Equally, a lengthy and apparently disorganised complaint may uncover a genuine workplace problem that needs addressing.
What should HR check before responding?
Use this quick checklist when an AI-generated grievance lands in your inbox:
AI-generated grievance checklist
- Read the whole grievance before reaching conclusions.
- Identify the specific allegations that require investigation.
- Separate facts from opinions and legal terminology.
- Check dates, names and events against your records.
- Identify relevant evidence, including emails, messages and policies.
- Speak to the employee to clarify anything unclear.
- Give relevant people an opportunity to respond where appropriate.
- Keep an impartial record of your investigation.
- Follow your organisation's grievance procedure.
- Communicate clearly about timescales and next steps.
- Avoid making assumptions based on the tone or sophistication of the writing.
The key is consistency. An employee should not receive a different standard of investigation (for better or worse) because they used AI to help write their complaint.
What does a fair grievance process look like?
Your grievance policy should be easy for employees and managers to find and understand.
It should explain:
- How employees can raise a concern.
- Who they should speak to.
- When an informal conversation may be appropriate.
- How to submit a formal grievance.
- What happens after a grievance is submitted.
- How meetings and investigations work.
- When an employee can be accompanied.
- How the outcome will be communicated.
- How an employee can appeal.
The Acas Code of Practice emphasises fairness, consistency, prompt handling, appropriate investigation and giving employees an opportunity to put their case.
Could AI actually improve your grievance process?
Potentially, yes.
Rather than viewing AI-generated grievances purely as an HR headache, consider what they tell you about how employees communicate today.
If an employee uses AI because they don't know how to structure a complaint, perhaps your organisation needs a simpler grievance guide.
If employees regularly submit lengthy complaints because they don't know what information HR needs, perhaps your grievance form could provide clearer prompts.
For example:
· What happened?
· When did it happen?
· Who was involved?
· What evidence do you have?
· What outcome are you hoping for?
This gives employees a straightforward way to explain their concerns while making it easier for HR to identify the information needed to investigate.
What does this mean for the wider HR team?
As workplace technology evolves, HR professionals increasingly need a combination of people skills, judgement and attention to detail.
That is particularly relevant when you're recruiting office-based HR, administration and customer service professionals.
Love Success's experience working with organisations demonstrates how important it is to understand not simply whether someone can perform a task, but whether they have the communication skills and judgement to work effectively within a particular environment. Those human skills matter even more when technology is doing more of the routine work while also potentially creating more work.
The ability to listen carefully, identify what really matters, ask the right questions and deal with people sensitively cannot be replaced by AI.
FAQs about AI-generated grievances
Can an employee use ChatGPT to write a grievance?
There is no general reason to dismiss a grievance simply because an employee has used AI to help write it. The important consideration is the substance of the complaint and the evidence behind it.
Can an employer refuse an AI-generated grievance?
You should not reject a legitimate grievance simply because it has been written or structured using AI. Follow your normal grievance process and investigate the concerns raised.
Should employees tell HR if they have used AI?
You may choose to include guidance on this in your AI policy. However, the more important issue is ensuring employees understand that they remain responsible for checking the accuracy and confidentiality of anything they submit.
What if an AI-generated grievance contains false information?
Investigate the relevant claims in the normal way. AI-generated wording should not automatically be treated as evidence. Establish the facts using appropriate records, witnesses and other available information.
How can employers reduce lengthy grievances?
Make your grievance process easy to understand and give employees clear prompts about the information you need. Encourage early conversations where appropriate, while making it clear that serious concerns can still be raised formally.
How should employers respond to AI-generated grievances?
The arrival of AI-written grievances doesn't mean HR needs an entirely new approach. It means you may need to become even better at separating communication from evidence.
Don't judge the grievance by the sophistication of their writing. Don't assume every AI-generated statement is accurate. And don't allow a 5,000-word document to obscure the relatively simple question at its centre: what happened, and what needs to be done about it?
And if your HR or office support team needs additional people with the communication, organisation and judgment needed to manage today's increasingly complex workplace, we can help you find experienced office and support professionals across London and the UK and we can specifically help you find HR staff with the skills needed to work with the challenges AI brings.