Creating a fair and inclusive recruitment process starts long before you review a CV. As a hiring manager, you’re not just assessing candidates; you’re shaping the conditions in which they present themselves. And those conditions are often influenced by deeply rooted societal biases that can quietly skew outcomes.
If you want to attract and secure the best talent, it’s on you to actively level the playing field.
Bias starts before the application
Recent insights reveal that many women undervalue themselves before recruitment even begins. Research shows that women are less likely to apply for an opportunity unless they meet 100% of the criteria, whereas men tend to apply when they meet around 60%.
This isn’t about capability - it’s about confidence, conditioning, and perception. If your role descriptions are overly rigid or packed with “must-haves”, you may unintentionally discourage strong candidates from even putting themselves forward.
As a hiring manager, you need to recognise that the talent pool is already filtered before it reaches you, and not always in a way that reflects true potential.
Rethink how you define “the ideal candidate”
It’s easy to fall into the trap of creating a checklist of requirements based on a previous hire or a “perfect” profile. But this approach often reinforces bias.
Instead, focus on what genuinely matters for success in the role. Ask yourself:
- Which skills are essential, and which can be developed?
- Are you prioritising experience over capability?
- Could your criteria exclude capable candidates from diverse backgrounds?
By broadening your definition of suitability, you open the door to a more varied and potentially higher-performing talent pool.
Structure your process to reduce subjectivity
Unstructured interviews and informal assessments leave too much room for unconscious bias. You might favour candidates who feel familiar or align with your own communication style without even realising it.
A more structured approach helps you make fairer decisions:
- Use consistent interview questions for all candidates
- Score responses against clear criteria
- Involve multiple stakeholders in the decision-making process
This doesn’t remove human judgment, but it ensures it’s applied more evenly.
Pay attention to language and messaging
The way you communicate an opportunity matters. Gendered language, overly corporate jargon, or unrealistic expectations can all influence who feels encouraged to apply.
Simple changes can make a significant difference:
- Use neutral, inclusive language
- Avoid unnecessary qualifications or years of experience
- Highlight flexibility, development, and support
You’re not just describing a role - you’re signalling who belongs.
Understand confidence gaps in interviews
Bias doesn’t disappear once candidates enter the process. Confidence gaps can show up in interviews, where some candidates may undersell their achievements or hesitate in their responses. This doesn’t mean they lack ability.
As a hiring manager, you should look beyond delivery style and focus on substance. Probe deeper, ask follow-up questions, and create space for candidates to fully demonstrate their strengths.
Make fairness part of your hiring strategy
Creating a level playing field isn’t a one-off adjustment. It requires ongoing awareness, reflection, and refinement of your processes. When you actively work to remove bias, you don’t just improve fairness, but you also improve hiring outcomes. You access a broader, more diverse talent pool and make decisions based on potential, not perception.
Partner with us for inclusive, high-quality hiring.